# North Star Pilot Competency Scorecard

> **Sample rubric:** This draft illustrates the proposed review model. Ratings and verification are valid only when issued through an approved North Star program by an authorized reviewer.

**Participant:**

**Reviewer:**

**Review date:**

**Program dates:**

## Rating scale

| Rating | Meaning |
|---:|---|
| 1 | Requires step-by-step support |
| 2 | Developing; completes portions with frequent support |
| 3 | Meets pilot standard with normal review |
| 4 | Strong; works independently on scoped tasks |
| 5 | Exceptional for the pilot level; produces consistently review-ready work |

## Competencies

| Area | Rating | Evidence | Reviewer notes |
|---|---:|---|---|
| Investigation process |  |  |  |
| Evidence selection |  |  |  |
| Timeline construction |  |  |  |
| Technical accuracy |  |  |  |
| Scope and limitation awareness |  |  |  |
| Incident/report writing |  |  |  |
| Risk communication |  |  |  |
| Remediation recommendations |  |  |  |
| Status communication |  |  |  |
| Deadline reliability |  |  |  |
| Feedback adoption |  |  |  |
| Professional integrity |  |  |  |

## Required outcomes

- [ ] Required work products completed
- [ ] At least one deliverable revised after feedback
- [ ] Portfolio artifacts sanitized and approved
- [ ] Resume claims match verified activities
- [ ] Final presentation or defense completed
- [ ] Participation record is supported by program records

## Final determination

**Result:** In progress / Completed / Completed with distinction / Not completed

**Reference eligibility:** Eligible / Limited / Not eligible

**Verified title:**

**Summary of demonstrated strengths:**


**Areas for continued development:**


**Reviewer signature:**

**Date:**